What Can You Not Add in a Protein Shake? Common Mistakes to Watch For

Knowing what can you not add in a protein shake is just as important as knowing what to include. Protein shakes are a popular choice for those looking to support their fitness and health goals. They’re an easy way to boost your protein intake.

But adding the wrong ingredients can reduce the benefits or bring in unnecessary extras your body doesn’t need. In this blog, we’ll explore the ingredients you should avoid, ensuring your protein shake remains a clean, effective boost to your routine.

Key findings:

What can you not add in a protein shake?

When crafting your ideal protein shake, it’s important to know what can you not add in a protein shake to keep it effective and beneficial. Including certain ingredients can hinder your fitness goals or affect your health in unintended ways.

1. Artificial sweeteners

Artificial sweeteners might seem like a good choice since they add sweetness without extra calories. However, they can negatively impact gut health and metabolism. Some studies  suggest that these sweeteners may also alter the balance of gut bacteria, potentially leading to digestive discomfort. Opting for natural sweeteners like honey or maple syrup, in moderation, can be a better alternative.

2. Carrageenan

Carrageenan is often used as a thickening agent in protein shakes and other beverages. While it enhances texture, it has been linked to digestive issues and may contribute to inflammation in the gut. Choosing a protein shake without carrageenan can help you avoid these potential problems. Always check the ingredient list to ensure your shake is free from this additive.

3. Soy protein

Though soy protein is popular in plant-based shakes, it comes with concerns. Some research points to its potential effects on hormone levels, while others highlight the risk of allergenic reactions in some individuals. If you’re questioning can you drink protein shakes without working out, be mindful that the type of protein you choose matters, and soy may not be the best fit for everyone.

4. Dairy

Including dairy in your protein shake may seem like a good idea, but it can cause problems for some. Full-fat milk or cream can lead to digestive discomfort, especially for individuals who are lactose intolerant or sensitive to dairy. Even if you’re not lactose intolerant, heavy dairy products can make your shake harder to digest and may cause bloating or gas.

5. Fillers

Many protein powders include fillers to bulk up the product, but they don’t add any nutritional value. These fillers, often listed as “protein blends” or vague ingredients, can lower the quality of your shake. They can also lead to bloating or discomfort after consumption. For a cleaner shake, choose products that are free of unnecessary fillers.

6. Dextrins / Maltodextrin

Dextrins and maltodextrin are common additives in protein powders, used as thickeners or fillers. While they might improve texture, they’re highly processed and can cause spikes in blood sugar, making them a poor choice for some. These additives offer little nutritional value and may be best avoided if you’re looking for a balanced shake that supports stable energy levels.

7, Skim Milk Powders

Skim milk powders are often used in protein shakes as a lower-fat dairy alternative, but they come with downsides. These powders are highly processed and lack the same nutritional benefits as fresh dairy or plant-based milk. For those looking to maximize the health benefits of their protein shake, fresh milk alternatives are a better option.

What to mix protein powder with?

Knowing what to mix protein powder with can make all the difference in reaching your health goals. The liquid you choose depends on your dietary preferences and desired results. Here are three popular options:

Water

Can you mix protein powder with water? Absolutely. Water is the simplest and most convenient choice. It’s perfect for those looking to avoid extra calories or dairy. By mixing protein powder with water, you get a fast, no-frills shake that’s easy to digest and low in calories. This option is especially good for people on calorie-restricted diets or those with lactose sensitivity.

Milk

Is protein powder better with water or milk? It depends on your goals. Milk provides additional protein, fats, and carbohydrates, making it a great option if you’re looking to boost calorie intake. Milk also adds creaminess and improves the texture of the shake, making it more satisfying. For those needing extra calories, especially after workouts, mixing your protein powder with milk is a solid choice.

Smoothies

For a more nutrient-dense option, blending your protein powder into a smoothie is an excellent idea. You can mix in fruits, vegetables, and other ingredients like collagen and bone broth together to create a meal replacement packed with vitamins, minerals, and fiber. Wondering how much collagen is in bone broth? Adding bone broth to a smoothie gives an additional protein boost, making it a versatile base for your shake.

You can easily boost your protein shake’s nutritional value with trumeta Bone Broth Protein. Tested at 98% purity, it delivers a clean, high-quality source of protein with no fillers or fluff. Made from meaty beef bones, it’s packed with over 30 amino acids, vitamins, and minerals, providing a powerhouse of nutrition. 

The powder is convenient and comes in a delicious all-natural cocoa flavor, making it a perfect addition to your shake. Whether you’re mixing with water, milk, or blending into a smoothie, trumeta bone broth protein supports your goals with rich, whole-food protein.

Conclusion

When deciding what can you not add in a protein shake, it’s important to choose ingredients that support your health goals. Avoid artificial sweeteners, carrageenan, soy protein, and fillers that can reduce the nutritional value of your shake. Understanding what to avoid in protein powder helps you create a cleaner, more effective shake that works with your body, not against it. Whether you mix it with water, milk, or blend it into a smoothie, selecting the right ingredients ensures your protein shake supports your fitness and dietary needs without unnecessary additives.